The best overall clipless MTB pedal in this roundup is the Shimano PD-ME700, a trail-focused SPD option with a larger surrounding platform than Shimano’s compact M520 and M540 pedals. For value, the Shimano PD-M520 stands out as a straightforward two-sided SPD design, while the Crankbrothers Candy offers four-sided entry for riders who prize quick engagement. The main tradeoffs are platform support versus low weight, familiar SPD compatibility versus a different cleat system, and a dedicated clipless pedal versus a dual-sided flat-and-clipless design. Your shoe, riding style, and preference for easy release matter as much as the pedal itself. Read on for the full comparison and recommendations by rider type.
Get sports gear delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
Complete the kit
Key Takeaways
- Shimano SPD models lead on familiar compatibility: the M520 and M540 are compact, practical picks, while the ME700 adds a broader trail-oriented support area.
- Crankbrothers pedals favor different priorities: Candy gives XC and trail riders four-sided entry, Eggbeater keeps things minimal, and Mallet targets riders who want more platform around the clip mechanism.
- Dual-sided hybrid pedals solve a specific problem: the Double Shot, PD-EH500, ROCKBROS, MZYRH, and BUCKLOS options let riders choose between a flat side and clipless engagement, but add bulk compared with dedicated pedals.
- Cleat-system choice affects more than pedal fit: Shimano SPD and Crankbrothers use different cleat designs, so shoe compatibility, release feel, and replacement preferences should guide the decision.
- The lineup separates by use, not just features: the simplest value picks suit riders who want dependable clip-in function, while platform-heavy and hybrid designs make more sense for trail support or mixed-use riding.
| Shimano PDM520 SPD Bicycle Cycling Pedals Black with Cleats |  | Best Straightforward SPD Pick | Material: Aluminum | Color: Black, silver | Weight: 380 g | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Shimano PD-M540 SPD Pedals |  | Best for Dedicated Trail Riding | Material: Chromium-molybdenum steel | Color: Black | Weight: 16 oz | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| MZYRH Dual Function MTB Mountain Bike Pedals with Aluminum Body and Cleats |  | Best for Clipless-and-Flat Flexibility | Material: CNC aluminum alloy | Weight: 13.44 oz | Dimensions: 3.94 × 3.54 in | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Crankbrothers Candy Clip-In MTB Bike Pedal – Gravel/XC/Trail Lightweight Bicycle Pedal, 4 Sided Entry, Customizable Float, Premium Bearings |  | Best Lightweight Trail and XC Pick | Material: Composite | Weight: 294 g | Measurements: 3.3 × 2.75 in | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Crankbrothers Double Shot MTB Hybrid Pedals |  | Best for Trail-to-Town Use | Material: Aluminum and chromium-molybdenum steel | Weight: 395 g | Color: Orange/black | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| ROCKBROS SPD MTB Pedals Dual Function Clipless Flat Bike Pedals |  | Best for Switching Between Clipless and Flat Shoes | Material: Nylon | Weight: 0.42 kg | Color: Black | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| ROCKBROS SPD Compatible MTB Pedals, Dual Function Clipless Flat Pedals |  | Best Aluminum Dual-Function Pick | Material: Aluminum alloy and stainless steel | Size: 101 x 92 mm | Weight: 440 g | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Shimano PD-M520 SPD Pedals |  | Best Straightforward Clipless Choice | Intended use: Mountain biking | Type: Clipless click pedal | Compatibility: SPD | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Shimano PD-ME700 Pedals |  | Best for a Wider Clipless Platform | Material: Chrome-moly spindle | Weight: 0.54 kg | Dimensions: 7.87 x 3.15 inches | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Crankbrothers Mallet MTB Bike Pedal |  | Best for Enduro and Unclipped Traction | Material: Aluminum | Weight: 419 g | Dimensions: 3.7 x 2.95 inches | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| SHIMANO PD-EH500 SPD & Flat Dual Sided Bike Pedal for Indoor Cycling & Urban Riding |  | Best for Urban Riding and Mixed Footwear | Material: Aluminum | Color: Black | Weight: 1.2 pounds | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Crankbrothers Eggbeater MTB Clip-in Pedals – Minimal, Lightweight XC/Gravel Pedals |  | Best for Lightweight, Muddy XC Riding | Intended use: Mountain biking and gravel | Pedal type: Clip-in | Compatible system: Crankbrothers | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| MZYRH MTB Mountain Bike Pedals Dual Function Sealed Aluminum 9/16″ Flat Platform with Cleats |  | Best for a Wide Platform and Shoe Flexibility | Material: Aluminum alloy | Size: 113 × 98 mm (4.45 × 3.86 in) | Weight: 500 g | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| BUCKLOS Mountain Bike Pedals Clip Flat Combo Compatible with SPD Cleats |  | Best Adjustable-Tension SPD Combo | Material: Aluminum | Size: 98 × 88 mm (3.86 × 3.46 in) | Weight: 14.4 ounces | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| clipless mtb pedal | Material | Weight | Thread size | Color |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Shimano PDM520 SPD Bicycle Cyc | Aluminum | 380 g | 9/16 in | Black, silver |
| Shimano PD-M540 SPD Pedals | Chromium-molybdenum steel | 16 oz | 9/16 in | Black |
| MZYRH Dual Function MTB Mounta | CNC aluminum alloy | 13.44 oz | 9/16 in | Black |
| Crankbrothers Candy Clip-In MT | Composite | 294 g | — | Black |
| Crankbrothers Double Shot MTB | Aluminum and chromium-molybdenum steel | 395 g | 0.56 in | Orange/black |
| ROCKBROS SPD MTB Pedals Dual F | Nylon | 0.42 kg | — | Black |
| ROCKBROS SPD Compatible MTB Pe | Aluminum alloy and stainless steel | 440 g | 9/16 inch | — |
| Shimano PD-M520 SPD Pedals | Chromoly steel | — | — | Silver |
| Shimano PD-ME700 Pedals | Chrome-moly spindle | 0.54 kg | 9/16 inches | — |
| Crankbrothers Mallet MTB Bike | Aluminum | 419 g | 110 | — |
| SHIMANO PD-EH500 SPD & Flat Du | Aluminum | 1.2 pounds | 45185 (as listed) | Black |
| Crankbrothers Eggbeater MTB Cl | Alloy steel | — | — | — |
| MZYRH MTB Mountain Bike Pedals | Aluminum alloy | 500 g | 9/16 inch | Black |
| BUCKLOS Mountain Bike Pedals C | Aluminum | 14.4 ounces | 9/16 inch | — |
More Details on Our Top Picks
Shimano PDM520 SPD Bicycle Cycling Pedals Black with Cleats
The Shimano PDM520 suits riders who want a conventional SPD clip-in setup without a flat platform or extra features. Its aluminum construction and included cleats make it a simple route into two-sided clipless riding, while the 380 g weight keeps it reasonably light. Compared with the more feature-rich Shimano PD-M540, the PDM520 is presented as the simpler option; the supplied details do not establish the same binding or bearing refinements. One limitation matters for this roundup: its listed bike type is road bike, so mountain-bike fit and trail use are less clearly supported than on the PD-M540. It also requires compatible cleated shoes, which makes it a less flexible choice for riders who alternate between regular footwear and clipless riding.
Pros:- Aluminum construction offers a durable pedal body
- SPD-compatible clipless connection provides a secure shoe attachment
- Cleats are included
- 380 g listed weight is relatively light
Cons:- Listed for road bikes, so mountain-bike suitability is less clearly specified than the PD-M540
- Requires compatible cleated shoes and does not offer a flat platform
- Product details provide less information about entry, release, and bearing features than the PD-M540
Best for: Adult riders with SPD-compatible shoes who want a simple clip-in pedal and mostly ride firm, predictable routes.
Not ideal for: Trail riders seeking a pedal explicitly specified for mountain bikes, or riders who want a flat side for ordinary shoes.
- Material:Aluminum
- Color:Black, silver
- Weight:380 g
- Measurements:6.3 × 4.72 in
- Thread size:9/16 in
- Listed bike type:Road bike
- Cleats:Included
Our verdict“Choose the PDM520 for a basic SPD setup with included cleats, but favor the PD-M540 if you want a pedal more clearly specified for mountain-bike use.”
Shimano PD-M540 SPD Pedals
The Shimano PD-M540 is the clearest fit here for riders prioritizing a purpose-specified mountain-bike SPD pedal. Its dual-sided entry means either side can face the shoe when clipping in, while fluorine-coated binding claws are intended to ease entry and release. Sealed bearings and chromoly spindles add durability-focused construction, and Shimano SH51 cleats are included. Compared with the MZYRH Dual Function, the M540 gives up the option of riding a flat side in regular shoes, but its dedicated clipless design is less of a compromise for riders who stay clipped in. The tradeoff is its listed 16-ounce weight and narrower use case: it is specified for mountain bikes, not as a hybrid pedal for commuting or casual footwear.
Pros:- Dual-sided design makes clip-in access more convenient
- Fluorine-coated binding claws are designed for easier entry and release
- Sealed bearings and chromoly spindles support durable use
- Shimano SH51 cleats are included
Cons:- At 16 ounces, it is heavier than the listed Crankbrothers Candy
- Clipless-only design is less versatile than the MZYRH Dual Function
- Specified primarily for mountain bikes rather than road or multi-use riding
Best for: Mountain bikers who ride clipped in consistently and want dual-sided SPD entry with included Shimano cleats.
Not ideal for: Riders who need a flat side for regular shoes or want a lighter, multi-use pedal for mixed riding.
- Material:Chromium-molybdenum steel
- Color:Black
- Weight:16 oz
- Dimensions:6.3 × 4.9 in
- Thread size:9/16 in
- Listed bike type:Mountain bike
- Included cleats:Shimano SH51
- Binding features:Dual-sided; fluorine-coated binding claws
- Bearings and spindle:Sealed bearings; chromoly spindle
Our verdict“Pick the PD-M540 if dedicated mountain-bike SPD function matters more to you than a flat side or minimum weight.”
MZYRH Dual Function MTB Mountain Bike Pedals with Aluminum Body and Cleats
The MZYRH Dual Function addresses a practical problem that the clipless-only Shimano PD-M540 does not: it offers both a clipless side and a flat side. That makes it a stronger match for riders who sometimes use cleated shoes and sometimes want ordinary footwear, or who want a less committed setup for mixed routes. Its CNC aluminum-alloy body and listed 13.44-ounce weight keep the design relatively light for a dual-function pedal, and the stated compatibility spans MTB, hybrid, road, and touring bikes. The added flexibility has a cost: buyers may need to adjust engagement tension to get clipping feel where they want it, and a flat/clipless combo cannot offer the same dedicated clip-in focus as the PD-M540. Cleated shoes remain necessary to use its clipless side.
Pros:- Dual-function design provides a clipless side and a flat side
- CNC aluminum-alloy body
- Listed weight is 13.44 oz
- Specified for MTB, mountain, hybrid, road, and touring bikes
Cons:- Clip engagement tension may need adjustment to suit the rider
- Flat-and-clipless layout is less dedicated to clip-in use than the Shimano PD-M540
- Clipless use still requires compatible cleated shoes
Best for: Hybrid and mountain-bike riders who alternate between cleated shoes and regular footwear, or want a flexible pedal for varied rides.
Not ideal for: Riders focused on technical trail riding who want a dedicated dual-sided clip-in pedal rather than a flat-and-clipless compromise.
- Material:CNC aluminum alloy
- Weight:13.44 oz
- Dimensions:3.94 × 3.54 in
- Thread size:9/16 in
- Color:Black
- Listed bike types:MTB, mountain, hybrid, road, touring
- Pedal design:Dual function: clipless and flat
- Installation:Directional markings
Our verdict“Choose the MZYRH if switching between cleated and regular shoes matters more than having a dedicated clipless pedal.”
Crankbrothers Candy Clip-In MTB Bike Pedal – Gravel/XC/Trail Lightweight Bicycle Pedal, 4 Sided Entry, Customizable Float, Premium Bearings
The Crankbrothers Candy is the specialist choice for riders who want a compact clip-in pedal for XC, gravel, or trail riding rather than a flat-sided hybrid. Its four-sided entry gives riders more angles from which to engage, and the design is described as shedding mud—useful when dirty conditions make a clean approach harder. At 294 g, it is substantially lighter than the 395 g Crankbrothers Double Shot, though that comparison comes with a smaller, clip-in-focused format rather than a flat platform for casual shoes. Customizable float and release angles let riders tune the cleat connection, while premium bearings and a double-seal system target smooth, protected operation. The tradeoffs are a potentially stiff initial engagement and less everyday versatility than the Double Shot.
Pros:- Four-sided entry offers multiple clip-in approach angles
- Mud-shedding design suits dirty trail conditions
- 294 g listed weight is lighter than the Double Shot
- Customizable float and release angles, with premium bearings and double seals
Cons:- Engagement may feel stiff initially
- Clipless-focused design lacks the Double Shot’s flat side for regular shoes
- Requires compatible cleats, which are necessary for clip-in use
Best for: Weight-conscious XC, gravel, and trail riders who want multiple entry angles and adjustable cleat feel.
Not ideal for: Riders who need a broad flat side for regular footwear or prefer a simpler, lower-adjustment pedal setup.
- Material:Composite
- Weight:294 g
- Measurements:3.3 × 2.75 in
- Color:Black
- Thread specification:110
- Listed bike types:Cyclocross bike, mountain bike
- Entry:Four-sided
- Adjustment:Customizable float and release angles
- Included components and warranty:Cleats included; 5-year warranty
Our verdict“Choose the Candy for a light, adjustable clip-in pedal for XC, gravel, or trail riding, and skip it if you need a flat side.”
Crankbrothers Double Shot MTB Hybrid Pedals
The Crankbrothers Double Shot is built for riders who want clipless engagement on one side and a usable flat surface on the other. That makes it more appealing for mixed mountain-bike, urban, and hiking use than the clip-in-only Crankbrothers Candy, whose lighter 294 g construction favors riders committed to cleated shoes. The Double Shot’s aluminum body and chromoly-steel spindle are paired with traction pads, pins, and a diamond-plate clip-in side, giving riders options when they do not want to clip in. At 395 g, it is the heaviest pedal in this five-product group by the listed weights, so dedicated XC riders may prefer the Candy or a conventional SPD pedal. The clip-in side also depends on Crank Brothers cleat compatibility.
Pros:- Combines a clip-in side with a flat side for mixed footwear
- Traction pads and pins add grip on the flat side
- Aluminum body and chromoly-steel spindle
- Listed for mountain-bike and multi-use riding
Cons:- At 395 g, it is heavier than the Crankbrothers Candy
- Clip-in side requires compatible Crank Brothers cleats
- Hybrid layout is less focused on clipless riding than a dedicated pedal such as the Shimano PD-M540
Best for: Mountain bikers and urban riders who sometimes ride in cleated shoes and sometimes want a flat pedal for regular footwear.
Not ideal for: Weight-focused XC riders or buyers who want a dedicated clipless pedal rather than a heavier two-sided compromise.
- Material:Aluminum and chromium-molybdenum steel
- Weight:395 g
- Color:Orange/black
- Style:Double Shot 2
- Thread size:0.56 in
- Spindle diameter:9/16 in
- Listed bike types:Mountain bike, multi-use
- Flat-side features:Traction pads and pins
- Clip-in compatibility:Crank Brothers cleats
Our verdict“Choose the Double Shot if you want one pedal for clipped-in rides and flat-shoe use, but pick the Candy for a lighter dedicated clip-in setup.”
ROCKBROS SPD MTB Pedals Dual Function Clipless Flat Bike Pedals
The dual-sided layout lets riders clip in on one face and use a flat shoe on the other, making these a flexible option for mixed-use rides or sharing a bike. Their wide contact area and non-slip screws give the flat side more support than a small clipless-only pedal, while sealed bearings help shield the mechanism from dust and water. Compared with the ROCKBROS SPD Compatible aluminum pedals, this model uses a nylon body, so it may be less suited to repeated rock strikes. The nylon construction also keeps the design aimed at everyday riding rather than hard-impact trails. Setup needs care: the tension adjustment can take some tuning, and riders who rarely use flat shoes may prefer the simpler, compact Shimano PD-M520.
Pros:- Dual-sided design supports clipless and flat-shoe riding
- Wide platform adds support when riding unclipped
- Sealed bearings help protect against dust and water
- Non-slip screws improve flat-side shoe grip
Cons:- Nylon body may be less resistant to severe impacts
- Tension adjustment requires careful setup
- Specified for adult mountain biking rather than a broad range of riders
Best for: Adult mountain-bike riders who alternate between flat and SPD-compatible shoes and want one pedal for casual trails and outdoor rides.
Not ideal for: Riders tackling rocky, aggressive trails or prioritizing impact resistance; the nylon body is a less reassuring choice than the aluminum ROCKBROS model.
- Material:Nylon
- Weight:0.42 kg
- Color:Black
- Bike type:Mountain bike
- Style:Flat and clipless
- Included components:Screws
- Unit count:2
- Warranty:1 year
Our verdict“Choose this ROCKBROS model if switching between flat and SPD-compatible shoes matters more than having an aluminum body for hard trail impacts.”
ROCKBROS SPD Compatible MTB Pedals, Dual Function Clipless Flat Pedals
This pair combines an SPD-compatible clipless side with a broad flat platform, but its CNC aluminum body is the key distinction from the nylon ROCKBROS dual-function option. That construction makes it the more compelling choice of the two for riders who want a sturdier-feeling platform, and anti-skid spikes help keep a flat shoe planted. The 101 x 92 mm size also gives the unclipped side useful room for repositioning your foot. The compromise is weight: at 440 g, it is heavier than the Shimano PD-M520, which is a more direct fit for riders who always clip in. Cleat setup takes extra attention, and the large hybrid profile is not the most focused choice for aggressive mountain biking. Its appeal is flexibility across mountain, road, and commuting use, not minimum weight.
Pros:- Dual-function design accommodates clipless and flat-shoe riding
- CNC aluminum body with stainless steel components
- Large platform and anti-skid spikes support unclipped footing
- SPD compatibility and included cleats suit varied bike use
Cons:- 440 g weight is higher than the Shimano PD-M520 pair specification
- Cleat setup and compatibility require attention
- Hybrid platform may be less suited to very aggressive mountain biking
Best for: Riders who use SPD-compatible shoes on some rides and flat shoes on others, and want an aluminum dual-function pedal for mountain, road, or commuting bikes.
Not ideal for: Weight-conscious riders who stay clipped in, or aggressive trail riders seeking a pedal designed specifically for hard mountain-bike use.
- Material:Aluminum alloy and stainless steel
- Size:101 x 92 mm
- Weight:440 g
- Thread size:9/16 inch
- Bike types:Mountain, road, commuter
- Compatibility:Shimano SPD
- Bearing type:Sealed bearings
- Platform grip:Anti-skid spikes
Our verdict“Pick this ROCKBROS pedal if you want an aluminum platform for both clipped-in and flat-shoe rides and can accept extra weight and setup.”
Shimano PD-M520 SPD Pedals
The PD-M520 is the focused choice here for riders who want a dependable SPD clipless pedal without a flat platform to add bulk. Its open binding is designed to make clipping in and out more manageable in tough conditions, while the chromoly spindle and sealed bearings suit regular trail use. At 380 g per pair, it is lighter than the 440 g ROCKBROS aluminum dual-function pedals, though that comparison comes with a different purpose: the ROCKBROS models offer flat-shoe support the M520 does not. The compact design makes sense for riders who stay clipped in, but it offers less underfoot support when unclipped than the Shimano PD-ME700. The listed package does not include cleats, so riders should account for that when choosing compatible footwear and setting up their bike.
Pros:- Open binding is designed for reliable entry and release in tough conditions
- Chromoly spindle and sealed bearings support durability
- Compact design avoids the extra platform of hybrid pedals
- Listed pair weight is 380 g
Cons:- Cleats are not included
- Fit and release tension may need adjustment
- Limited color option listed
Best for: Mountain bikers who already have SPD-compatible shoes and want a compact, clipless-only pedal for regular trail riding.
Not ideal for: Riders who want a flat side for unclipped sections or need cleats included; the dual-function ROCKBROS models offer more shoe flexibility.
- Intended use:Mountain biking
- Type:Clipless click pedal
- Compatibility:SPD
- Weight per pair:380 g
- Material:Chromoly steel
- Color:Silver
- Dimensions:7.87 x 3.15 inches
- Cleats:Not included
Our verdict“Choose the PD-M520 if you want a compact SPD pedal for clipped-in mountain biking and do not need a flat platform or included cleats.”
Shimano PD-ME700 Pedals
The wide body gives the PD-ME700 a more supportive feel than the compact Shimano PD-M520, making this the better fit for riders who want more pedal beneath their shoe while staying clipped in. Its adjustable retention claws let riders tune engagement and release tension to suit their comfort, and the chrome-moly spindle with sealed bearings is aimed at durable riding across cross-country and gravel use. This wider, more substantial design comes with a weight penalty: the listed 0.54 kg is heavier than the M520’s 380 g per-pair specification. It is also not a flat-and-clipless hybrid like the ROCKBROS pedals, so riders who want to ride in ordinary shoes should look elsewhere. Expect some setup time to find a release setting that feels right.
Pros:- Wide body provides more support under the shoe
- Adjustable retention claws allow release-tension tuning
- Chrome-moly spindle and sealed bearings support durability
- Suitable for cross-country and gravel riding
Cons:- Listed weight is higher than the Shimano PD-M520 specification
- Release tension may require setup and adjustment
- No flat platform for riding in ordinary shoes
Best for: Cross-country and gravel riders who prefer SPD-style clipless engagement with a broader body and adjustable release tension.
Not ideal for: Riders seeking the lightest compact option or a flat side for ordinary shoes; the PD-M520 is more compact, while ROCKBROS offers dual-function platforms.
- Material:Chrome-moly spindle
- Weight:0.54 kg
- Dimensions:7.87 x 3.15 inches
- Thread size:9/16 inches
- Bike type:Cross-country
- Engagement:Dual-sided
- Retention:Adjustable claws
- Bearings:Sealed
Our verdict“Choose the PD-ME700 if you value a wider clipless platform and adjustable release over the lighter, more compact PD-M520.”
Crankbrothers Mallet MTB Bike Pedal
The Crankbrothers Mallet is the most gravity-focused option in this group: its concave platform, ribbed body, and six adjustable pins per side are built to help keep a shoe planted when a rider is unclipped. That makes it a different proposition from the compact Shimano PD-M520, which prioritizes clipless engagement without comparable platform support. Traction pad technology and a customizable interface let riders tune the shoe-pedal contact, while two axle lengths offer a choice for bike clearance. The tradeoff is a more substantial, specialized pedal: at 419 g, it is heavier than the M520’s listed pair weight, and its enduro-oriented setup may be unnecessary for riders focused on cross-country or ordinary trail mileage. Buyers should also check which axle length suits their bike.
Pros:- Concave platform and adjustable pins help secure an unclipped shoe
- Traction pad technology and ribbed body add shoe contact
- Customizable interface supports rider-specific setup
- Two axle lengths provide a choice for bike clearance
Cons:- More substantial than minimalist clipless pedals
- Enduro-focused features may be unnecessary for less aggressive riding
- Axle-length choice requires checking bike clearance
Best for: Enduro and dual-suspension mountain-bike riders who want clipless engagement backed by a grippy platform for moments when they unclip.
Not ideal for: Cross-country riders prioritizing a compact, lighter pedal, or casual riders who do not need adjustable pins and a platform built for aggressive terrain.
- Material:Aluminum
- Weight:419 g
- Dimensions:3.7 x 2.95 inches
- Thread size:110
- Bike types:Dual-suspension mountain, mountain bike
- Platform:Concave with 6 adjustable pins per side
- Other features:Traction pad technology, ribbed body, chamfered edges
- Axle lengths:52 mm or 57 mm
Our verdict“Choose the Mallet if enduro riding calls for a clipless pedal with strong platform support when you need to unclip.”
SHIMANO PD-EH500 SPD & Flat Dual Sided Bike Pedal for Indoor Cycling & Urban Riding
The PD-EH500 suits riders who want SPD engagement without giving up a usable flat side. That makes it a more practical choice for errands, indoor cycling, or rides where you may switch between cycling shoes and sneakers than the Crankbrothers Eggbeater, which is built around clip-in use. Adjustable cleat tension lets riders tune the release feel, while the aluminum body keeps the design relatively light for a dual-sided pedal. The tradeoff is that its road-and-urban emphasis is less tailored to rough mountain-bike trails than dedicated MTB options, and the clip-in side requires compatible SPD cleats. I’d choose it for versatility on mixed-purpose rides, not for the lightest or most trail-focused setup.
Pros:- Flat side supports ordinary shoes when clip-in footwear is inconvenient
- SPD side offers a familiar clip-in option for compatible shoes
- Adjustable cleat tension allows riders to tailor release feel
- Aluminum construction balances durability with relatively low weight for a hybrid pedal
Cons:- Urban and road-oriented design is less suited to demanding MTB trail use
- SPD-side use requires compatible cleats
- A dual-sided format is less specialized than a dedicated clip-in pedal
Best for: Urban and indoor-cycling riders who want to use SPD shoes on some rides and ordinary sneakers on others
Not ideal for: Trail-focused mountain bikers seeking a dedicated MTB pedal with a broad, stable platform or a minimal clip-in design
- Material:Aluminum
- Color:Black
- Weight:1.2 pounds
- Dimensions:7 × 6 inches
- Thread size:45185 (as listed)
- Bike type:Road bike
- Pedal design:Dual-sided: flat platform and SPD clip-in
- Cleat tension:Adjustable
Our verdict“Choose the PD-EH500 if you value switching between sneakers and SPD shoes more than a trail-specific pedal design.”
Crankbrothers Eggbeater MTB Clip-in Pedals – Minimal, Lightweight XC/Gravel Pedals
For riders who prioritize low weight and reliable engagement in mud, the Eggbeater is the most specialized pick here. Its minimal, open design sheds mud more readily than the platform-style MZYRH MTB Dual Function, making it a stronger match for wet cross-country or gravel routes where packed dirt can interfere with a pedal. Customizable float and release angle add room to tune how the foot moves and disengages. The compromise is equally clear: there is no broad flat surface for ordinary shoes, and the compact design offers less underfoot support than platform-oriented options. Its float may also take adjustment to suit a rider’s preference. I’d pick it for clip-in efficiency and mud clearance, not casual versatility.
Pros:- Minimal design keeps the listed pair weight low
- Open mechanism is designed to shed mud
- Customizable float and release angle allow fit adjustments
- Premium bearings and a double seal system are specified for durability
Cons:- No flat platform for riding in ordinary shoes
- Compact contact area provides less support than platform-style pedals
- Float settings may require adjustment to find a comfortable feel
Best for: Cross-country and gravel riders who use clip-in shoes, want a lightweight pedal, and often ride in muddy conditions
Not ideal for: Riders who want to pedal in sneakers, prefer a large supportive platform, or want the straightforward feel of an SPD system
- Intended use:Mountain biking and gravel
- Pedal type:Clip-in
- Compatible system:Crankbrothers
- Weight per pair:280 g
- Material:Alloy steel
- Bike types:Cyclocross and mountain bike
- Float and release:Customizable
- Bearings and seals:Premium bearings; double seal system
- Warranty:5 years
Our verdict“Choose the Eggbeater for lightweight clip-in riding and mud clearance if you do not need a flat side or broad platform.”
MZYRH MTB Mountain Bike Pedals Dual Function Sealed Aluminum 9/16″ Flat Platform with Cleats
The MZYRH combines a wide 113 × 98 mm platform with a clip-in option, favoring stability and shoe flexibility over a lightweight feel. Its platform and anti-skid spikes give it a more substantial flat side than the compact BUCKLOS Clip Flat Combo, which may appeal to riders who want more area under ordinary shoes as well as cleat use. Three sealed bearings are specified to help protect the rotation from water and dust. That broad, dual-function construction comes with a weight penalty: at 500 g, it is a less appealing choice for riders trying to trim mass from a cross-country bike. Cleat and gasket installation also calls for some setup. I’d favor it for adaptable everyday MTB use, rather than weight-conscious riding.
Pros:- Wide platform offers substantial support for ordinary shoes
- Anti-skid spikes add grip on the flat side
- CNC aluminum alloy body is specified for durable construction
- Three sealed bearings are intended to protect against water and dust
Cons:- Listed 500 g weight is high for riders focused on minimizing bike weight
- Cleat and gasket installation adds setup work
- Bulkier platform design is less minimal than the Crankbrothers Eggbeater
Best for: Mountain bikers who want a roomy platform for ordinary shoes alongside a clip-in option and value stability over low weight
Not ideal for: Cross-country riders prioritizing a lightweight pedal, or buyers who want a ready-to-ride setup without cleat and gasket installation
- Material:Aluminum alloy
- Size:113 × 98 mm (4.45 × 3.86 in)
- Weight:500 g
- Thread size:9/16 inch
- Bearings:3 sealed bearings
- Color:Black
- Bike type:Mountain bike
- Design:Dual function with platform and cleat use
Our verdict“Choose the MZYRH if a broad, grippy platform and two shoe options matter more than keeping pedal weight low.”
BUCKLOS Mountain Bike Pedals Clip Flat Combo Compatible with SPD Cleats
The BUCKLOS is a flexible option for riders who want a flat side, SPD-compatible clip-in side, and a way to adjust engagement tension. Compared with the SHIMANO PD-EH500, it is presented for a broader spread of bike types, including MTB, gravel, and e-bikes; its 98 × 88 mm platform also makes it a more compact alternative to the wider MZYRH. CNC aluminum construction and sealed bearings suit regular mixed-surface use, though the listed weight of 14.4 ounces is not especially appealing to riders seeking a minimalist pedal. The other catch is that SPD cleats are not included, and tension adjustment may take some setup. This makes the most sense for multi-bike riders who value adaptability over a dedicated clip-in feel.
Pros:- Dual-sided design accommodates regular shoes and compatible clip-in shoes
- Adjustable tension allows riders to tune engagement and release
- CNC aluminum body and sealed bearings are specified for durable use
- Compatibility covers MTB, road, gravel, spinning, and e-bike applications
Cons:- SPD cleats are not included
- Listed weight is higher than a minimal clip-in pedal such as the Crankbrothers Eggbeater
- Tension adjustment may be complex for riders new to clipless pedals
Best for: Riders using MTB, gravel, road, or e-bikes who want an SPD-compatible pedal for both cycling shoes and ordinary footwear
Not ideal for: Weight-conscious XC riders or buyers who want cleats included and a simple, ready-to-use setup
- Material:Aluminum
- Size:98 × 88 mm (3.86 × 3.46 in)
- Weight:14.4 ounces
- Thread size:9/16 inch
- Compatibility:MTB, road, gravel, spinning, and e-bike
- Pedal design:Dual-sided flat and clip-in
- Bearings:Sealed bearings
- Tension:Adjustable
- Cleat compatibility:SPD-compatible; cleats not included
Our verdict“Choose the BUCKLOS if you want an adjustable SPD-compatible combo pedal across several bike types and can handle separate cleat setup.”
How We Picked
I compared these 14 clipless MTB pedals by the things that change the ride and ownership experience: entry and release design, shoe and cleat compatibility, platform support, intended terrain, and whether each pedal is clipless on one or both sides. I also weighed practical details such as construction, bearing claims where specified, and how much versatility a design offers against its added size or complexity. A feature matters here only when it helps a rider make a clearer choice, such as a wider support area for trail use or a flat face for riding in everyday shoes.
The ranking favors pedals with a clear purpose and a useful balance of control, usability, and compatibility. Shimano’s familiar SPD models rank well for riders seeking a direct, established setup; the ME700 gets the overall nod for its trail-oriented support. Crankbrothers earns distinct places for four-sided entry and minimalist or gravity-focused designs, while the hybrid models rank lower for dedicated clipless use because their extra flat side adds versatility but is not every rider’s priority. Similar models are separated by their stated design and role rather than treated as interchangeable.
Factors to Consider When Choosing Clipless Mtb Pedals
Before choosing clipless MTB pedals, I’d settle a few setup questions that can matter more than a small difference in pedal shape. These factors help match the pedal to your shoes, terrain, and comfort with clipping in and out.
Check the Cleat System Before Buying
Pedals and cleats work as a system, so start by checking which cleat standard your shoes support. Shimano SPD and Crankbrothers cleats are not interchangeable, and a shoe’s bolt pattern does not by itself guarantee the same release feel or shoe-pedal fit. If you already own compatible shoes, staying with that system avoids replacing more of your setup than necessary. If you are starting fresh, compare the cleat’s release options and how much walking you expect to do in your shoes. A common mistake is choosing a pedal first and discovering that the preferred shoe or cleat setup does not match. Factor cleat replacement and availability into long-term convenience, not just the pedal choice.
Match Platform Size to Terrain and Shoe
A compact mechanism can keep a pedal light and simple, but a larger surrounding platform can offer more contact and support under the shoe. That difference can matter on rough trails, where riders may value a steadier-feeling connection, and less on smoother XC routes where low bulk is a stronger priority. Platform size does not replace correct cleat position or a well-fitting shoe, so it should not be treated as a cure for foot discomfort. Also check whether the pedal’s shape suits your shoe sole; a broad body is useful only if it works with the shoe you plan to wear. Riders who spend time unclipped may value a platform differently from those who stay engaged for most of a ride. Choose support for your terrain rather than assuming the biggest body is always best.
Choose Between Dedicated and Hybrid Pedals
A dedicated clipless pedal keeps both sides focused on clip-in use, while a hybrid gives you a flat face for unclipped starts, casual shoes, or shared-bike situations. That flexibility has a cost: hybrids are typically larger and require you to orient the pedal to the side you want before setting off. Riders who alternate footwear often may accept that compromise, while riders who clip in for every ride may prefer a simpler dedicated design. Do not buy a hybrid just because it sounds like a safer beginner option; practice and cleat adjustment are still needed to build reliable release habits. Think about how often you will actually use the flat side, not just whether it might come in handy. If that use is rare, the extra pedal body may not earn its place.
Prioritize Entry and Release Feel
Entry design shapes how easily you can reconnect with the pedal after a dab or stop. A four-sided entry design can offer more places to engage, while a conventional two-sided pedal may feel more familiar to riders coming from common SPD setups. Release feel depends on the cleat and its adjustment as well as the pedal, so claims about easy entry do not guarantee that every rider will find unclipping comfortable. Beginners should set up cleats carefully and practice release while stationary before relying on the system on technical terrain. If you have limited ankle movement or a preferred foot-out direction, check the available cleat settings rather than guessing. A smooth, repeatable release is more useful than a feature that sounds fast but does not suit your movement.
Balance Weight Against Support and Durability
Lightweight designs can appeal to XC and gravel riders who want a minimal pedal, while trail and gravity riders may be happier with additional body around the mechanism. More material can provide a larger contact area, but it can also add bulk and may be unnecessary for smoother riding. Build and bearing details matter for long-term ownership, though a specific bearing label alone cannot predict service life in wet, gritty conditions. Consider how often you ride in mud, how comfortable you are with cleaning and maintenance, and whether replacement parts are easy to source for your chosen system. Avoid picking solely by the lowest weight or the longest feature list. The right balance depends on terrain, riding frequency, and how much support you want underfoot.
Treat Cleat Position as Part of the Purchase
Pedal choice is only one part of the connection: cleat placement affects release, foot position, and comfort. Before a long ride, check that both cleats are secure and placed consistently, then test engagement and release in a low-risk setting. Riders new to clipless pedals often set tension or cleat position by feel alone and skip the practice that reveals an awkward release angle. Keep in mind that changing pedal systems may also change the cleat shape and the way your shoe sits on the pedal. A setup that feels unfamiliar at first may need adjustment, but persistent discomfort is a reason to revisit shoe fit and cleat position rather than simply riding through it. Leave room in your decision for a careful setup, not just installation.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I use Shimano SPD shoes with Crankbrothers pedals?
Not by assuming the cleats are interchangeable: Shimano SPD and Crankbrothers use different cleat systems. Check the pedal maker’s stated compatibility and the shoe’s mounting setup before buying cleats or pedals. If you already own shoes fitted with SPD cleats, Shimano SPD pedals are the straightforward match in this lineup. Switching systems may mean changing cleats and adjusting to a different entry and release feel. Choose based on the complete shoe-and-cleat setup, not the pedal alone.
Are dual-sided clipless-and-flat pedals a good choice for someone new to clipless riding?
They can be useful if you also ride in regular shoes, share a bike, or want a flat face for short trips. They do not remove the need to learn how to clip in and release, and the pedal may need to be turned to the side you want before you start. A dedicated SPD pedal can be simpler if nearly every ride will be in compatible cycling shoes. For a new rider, practice unclipping while stopped and check cleat adjustment before riding technical trails. Pick a hybrid for its real flat-pedal use, not as a substitute for learning the clipless system.
Should I choose the Shimano PD-M520 or PD-ME700 for trail riding?
The M520 makes more sense if you want a compact, straightforward SPD pedal and do not need a larger surrounding platform. The ME700 is the more trail-oriented choice in this group because its broader body is aimed at adding shoe support around the clip mechanism. That support may be more appealing on rougher rides, while the M520’s simpler footprint suits riders who prefer a less bulky design. Your shoes also affect how much benefit you get from added platform area. Choose the ME700 for the platform-focused design; choose the M520 when familiar SPD function and a compact form matter more.
Do Crankbrothers Eggbeater pedals make sense for trail riding?
The Eggbeater’s minimal design is most compelling when low bulk and a simple XC or gravel-oriented setup are priorities. Riders who want more shoe support or a broader pedal body should look at the Candy or Mallet instead, since those models have more surrounding structure. Trail suitability depends on your shoe, terrain, and preference for support, not the name of the pedal alone. Compare the system’s cleat and release feel with your needs before changing from SPD. If you regularly ride rough trails and want a larger contact area, the Eggbeater may not be the best fit among these options.
What should I check if clipless pedals feel hard to release?
Start by checking that the cleats are the correct type for the pedals, firmly attached, and not excessively worn. Review the cleat position and any release-angle or tension settings supported by your chosen system, then practice unclipping while stationary. Mud or debris around the pedal and cleat can also interfere with engagement or release, so clean both when needed. If the movement remains uncomfortable, compare your technique and shoe setup rather than forcing the foot through pain. For a new rider, avoid testing an unfamiliar release setup for the first time on a steep or technical section.
Conclusion
For most riders seeking a dedicated trail pedal, I’d start with the Shimano PD-ME700 as best overall, thanks to its more supportive trail-oriented body and familiar SPD system. The Shimano PD-M520 is my best-value pick for riders who want a compact, uncomplicated SPD setup, while the Crankbrothers Candy is my best premium-style choice for riders drawn to four-sided entry and a distinct cleat system. Beginners who already have SPD-compatible shoes can start with the PD-M520 and spend time on cleat setup and release practice; those who need an option for everyday shoes should consider a hybrid such as the Crankbrothers Double Shot or Shimano PD-EH500. For specific needs, choose the Eggbeater for a minimal XC/gravel setup, the Mallet for a more platform-focused gravity-oriented pedal, or a dual-sided ROCKBROS, MZYRH, or BUCKLOS model when the flat face will see regular use. Match the cleats to your shoes and the pedal’s shape to your terrain, and the shortlist becomes much easier to narrow.
